Declining Wages and Weird Ideas

Election season is upon us. Which reminds me of Andrew Yang’s book The War on Normal People (Hachette Book Group, 2018).
If you didn’t know, Andrew Yang was a 2020 presidential candidate in the Democratic primaries, and later a NYC mayoral candidate.
I’m not gonna lie, Andrew Yang had some weird ideas. He also had a very comprehensive plan for the country with a lot of good ideas, like teaching both financial and emotional proficiency in schools, and refocusing capitalism on human welfare over profit alone.
Yet his biggest claim to fame (and the premise of his book and his candidacies) is that technology is making millions of jobs obsolete. Since companies will soon profit from automated software, robots, and AI (artificial intelligence), corporations will need to share some of their profits with the humans that technology replaced. Therefore, universal basic income (UBI) is the future.
Universal basic income has been shown to work in many studies on real communities, especially when targeted to specific groups of people. But no one knows how it would work on a grand scale. I fear it could increase inflation even more, or cause other unforeseen issues. But who knows?
The real problem in my view, as Andrew Yang convincingly shows in his book, is the fact that wages and benefits for CEOs and top earners has greatly increased, while lower-income and median wages have stagnated—in some cases for decades! No wonder so many people feel stuck!
“Today, inequality has surged to historic levels,” Yang writes. “The top 1 percent have accrued 52 percent of the real income growth in America since 2009… Studies have shown that everyone is less happy in an unequal society—even those at the top. The wealthy experience higher levels of depression and suspicion in unequal societies…” (pp. 15-16).
There’s a lot to think about in that one passage (his book is worth the read). The main takeaway I got from The War on Normal People is that we need to increase wages for the bottom 80%; decrease wasteful wages, benefits, and tax breaks for corporations and the top 1 to 20 percent of earners; and refocus our priorities on communities and quality of life rather than profits to shareholders.
Easier said than done. Though Yang might argue that raising wages won’t matter if jobs disappear altogether, hence the need for UBI. But this isn’t a new idea.
An article in The Washington Post by Jenny Singer said that, according to some 20th century philosophers, by now technology should make work so efficient that “leisure would eclipse labor” and we should be living in the “golden age of hobbies.” But those philosophers also warned that “the powerful and rich among us” will want to keep us “in bondage and slavery for their profit.”
Technology has been “replacing” many of our jobs since the industrial revolution. And yet, we keep working.
Why aren’t we living in the golden age of hobbies? Are the powerful and rich purposefully keeping the masses working for low wages for their benefit?
I don’t think we will ever completely replace the human workforce—or the humanity—in our daily work and lives, and I doubt we would want to. We humans want to work, be purposeful, and earn money.
At the same time, we want work-life balance and to experience things outside of work. Yet our “work-life balance” is anything but. Which is partly why the internet is filled with click-bait articles like “Millennial only works 2 days a week” and “Blogger makes $10k a month” and so on. However unrealistic, we want it to be true.
Shouldn’t technology make this possible? Shouldn’t we have more time with our families? Or time to write that novel or memoir we’ve always dreamed about?
I don’t have all the answers. But I think there’s a real case for 6-hour workdays or 4-day workweeks. Many studies (like this one) have shown that productivity is the same—or even increases—when employees have better work-life balance. The same has been shown when employees are allowed to work from home.
I’d love to know your thoughts! Do you think we should be working less because of technology? Are the powerful and rich keeping us in bondage for their profit? Is universal basic income a good idea? What would you do if you had more free time?
(Don’t forget to do your research and make sure your voice is heard on November 3rd—not just for big positions but for local ones as well.)
If you liked this, subscribe to my blog and download my free e-booklet How to Write Your Book: Everything You Need for Your Legacy on my website https://andreakuhlman.com.